Posts Tagged ‘skateboard parks’

Town Council of Oakville is anti-community

Monday, June 14th, 2010

EDITORIAL

Skateboard relocation decision is anti-community! It flies in the face of a community with people, all people as their first priority.

[Editor: Read more about the West Oaks skateboard relocation here , here, & here.]

The Town of Oakville has become the real life setting for "The Truman Show". Beautiful, and controlled but not for all the people of the Town Of Oakville.

Oakville, through its governing decisions and by-laws, is attempting to sanitize our community under the mistaken catch phrase of becoming a "Livable Oakville".

Every issue that comes before this misguided council involves the sloganeering about making Oakville "livable". This is jingoism or "sloganism" at its worst. This is social engineering being done badly.

Historically in 2008, the Town passed the following: "Livable Oakville is the Town’s new Official Plan".

"The Livable Oakville Plan" is the first step in fleshing out the vision ‘To be the most livable town in Canada’. The new plan ensures that Oakville develops into a complete community that includes:

  1. a full mixture of housing types to meet the changing demographics of the Town over time, including opportunities for more affordable housing types
  2. a broad range of employment opportunities, including office and industrial uses a variety of forms of retail uses, including historic main streets, malls and
    large-format stores
  3. an array of health and educational facilities and other institutional uses that
    serve the entire population
  4. protection of the environment and an appropriate mixture of public park and trail networks that promote active living
  5. a transportation system that connects Oakville to the broader region and accommodates automobiles but also promotes the use of other modes of travel including transit, cycling and walking"

Residents should see in the documents related to planning a livable Oakville, that what is missing is "people".

People don’t exist in their plans or thinking and decisions made are NOT people friendly unless they are trying to please a vocal community group, or street or a ratepayer with property. The key here is property. This Council is only interested in decisions that can procure votes from the most vocal, who are always the property owner. You cannot build a “livable community” by creating a new by-law for only the most vocal.

My oversight of this Council sees that more and more people and a lively community are not part of the planning process. This is about bricks and mortar and not about people. Decisions made are not about a lively community on the streets being out and active in our community, twenty-four seven. This Council is about money and power to those already empowered.

The skateboard decision is the perfect example of decisions cloaked in bureaucracy and it is anti-people. It is anti-children. It is anti-play unless you go to the outer limits of the Town. This was the case with the anti-lights on school playing fields. They preached NIMBYISM at every meeting.

This Council’s real motto is “Sanitize Oakville” and they hide this under the guise of a "Livable Oakville".

If it moves, regulate it. If people want to use parks deny them or regulate them. If businesses make good economic decisions they don’t like go to war with them. If school boards don’t adhere to their thinking call them arrogant and pass more by-laws. Yet ask them to clean up goose guano from parks so people can actually use them and nothing happens.

In this case – skateboard parks – they are willing to metaphorically "euthanize" noisy children by moving them to the “nether-lands”. God forbid we should have children in our parks. God forbid we should have field lighting in many of our parks. Children and play are being banned in Oakville.

This Council continues to show the world that we are anti-business and anti-people by creating impulsive and arrogant, nonsense by-laws which will denude Oakville of any industry that is not lily white. Now they are embarked on a denuding Oakville of people on the streets and in the community.

The Town of Oakville attacks our largest employers and industries because they dare to think for themselves and not in unison with the Council under the misstated "Livable Community" philosophy. Council has in the past two years attacked Ford, the Halton Catholic District School Board and others because they have mandates different than the Truman Show agenda of the Town of Oakville.

The Council vision of the best community is one that is pure and out of site and rocks no boats. What should become apparent to thinking people is that this new philosophy is strongly anti-people.

Communities that are viable in the long term are vibrant and alive. Sure we are no New York City and neither is Toronto, but one just has to go to New York City and you will see neighbourhood and corner parks with playgrounds that have made the city livable again. Basketball and bocce ball till midnight or later on many corners. Places where people can go with being overly regulated.

This “sanitize and call it livable“ planning philosophy is setting the future for an unsafe and overly controlled Oakville. Planners and architects know this is counter to Jane Jacobs thinking because PEOPLE are the community.

A community is not the bricks, the streets and the by-laws. A community is the PEOPLE, all the people.

Out of sight is not out of mind. Council needs to change this anti-people philosophy. There are consultations but these are street theatre because Council has directed staff to make changes before second meetings. This was the case in the skateboard park decision.

Change this pandering to the whining and wealthy! This is not a philosophy, it is a choice.

It is a choice that in future years all the citizens of Oakville will pay a heavy price for in our community, where people are not welcome and businesses are driven from our midst.

- William A. Hoch

Council decision on skateboard park solves nothing

Sunday, June 13th, 2010
West Oaks skateboard park

West Oaks skateboard park to be moved to Palermo Park.

EDITORIAL by Michael Burton

For more information on the skateboard park issue, please read our article titled Debate over skateboard parks in Oakville and our follow up article titled Does moving West Oak skateboard park solve the problem? where Council members Marc Grant and Roger Lapworth provide statements on this issue.

On Tuesday May 26th I arrived at the Oakville council chamber to report on the issue of the late night disturbances of the West Oak Skateboard Park. I arrived 20 minutes early – with four or five residents waiting for the meeting to begin.

The first meeting

In the back row, just like the back-of-the-classroom jokers in high school, sat roughly ten skateboarders. Many dressed casually, their tattoos fully visible, hunched over the railing in front of them. Respectfully they waited for the meeting to begin, they had arrived long before I did.

Skateboarders sat on the right hand side of the room – town residents on the other. There was a clear division between residents. The room was now full – with more than 50 residents attending the meeting. However – there wasn’t any tension in the room, it was relaxed and residents even chuckled at the odd joke.

When the issue was brought up for discussion, one-by-one children, skateboarders, and residents had their say. Skateboarders from the ages of five to 25 asked not to remove the park – and the older skateboarders high-fived younger skateboarders after they made their speech. It was a heart-warming moment for everyone in the room.

At that moment in time it really seemed like the youth of Oakville had the upper hand on the issue. They had made their case, and explained that this park has incredible meaning to them.

Residents had their say, outlining that the noise created late at night prevented them from sleeping within their own homes with their windows open. Skateboarders made their pitch – saying that the ones causing trouble late at night weren’t even skateboarders.

The decision that night was to defer the issue to another meeting on June 1st.

A very different second meeting

“We will have our community officers continue to work with Town staff to ensure that the park is equipped with sufficient lighting and open spaces to deter unlawful activity in an effort to make this park as safe as possible.”
– Sergeant Brian Carr, Public Affairs Bureau

I arrived at the second meeting to something very different. No skateboarders, no children begging not to move the park. The only resident I recognized from the first meeting was Craig Ferguson – who had planned a power-point presentation for this meeting.

Did everyone miss the memo? What happened? Where were the thralls of people that voiced their opinion the first time? The original fifty or so people that came to the meeting were nowhere to be found.

Ferguson made his pitch – Chris Mark, Oakville’s Parks and Open Space Director gave his report to council with a budget in place to move the park.

Councillor Marc Grant made one last effort to save the park, “Where do we stop telling kids they can’t do things in Oakville because it ruins our enjoyment of the community?” he asked.

The decision

The motion was then passed to move the skateboard park to Palermo Park, Councillor Grant shook his head in disappointment as the decision was made.

This didn’t happen in front of all those concerned residents, skateboarders, and little kids from the first meeting. There I sat in an empty row, watching the end of the West Oak skateboard park.

The Halton Regional Police failed to attend both meetings. I’m curious as to whether or not they missed the memo as well. Their insight could have changed the outcome.

UPDATE: We received the following response from the Halton Region Police Service:

The Halton Regional Police Service will continue to patrol and monitor this park like we would any other. We will continue to enforce bylaws, provincial and federal laws, as they present themselves.

We will have our community officers continue to work with Town staff to ensure that the park is equipped with sufficient lighting and open spaces to deter unlawful activity in an effort to make this park as safe as possible.

- Sergeant Brian Carr, Public Affairs Bureau

Many skateboarders might believe that it is their right to skateboard – but it is not a right for them to have access to skateboard parks. The town gave these parks to the youth, and it’s in the youth’s hands to use them appropriately. Town council made a poor decision to move the park, and those ten year olds that could skateboard in their own backyard. Now, have to cross busy Dundas Street to get to Palermo Park.

Does moving West Oak skateboard park solve the problem?

Wednesday, June 2nd, 2010

Oakville Town Council voted yesterday in favour of removing the West Oak skateboard park and moving it to Palermo Park at an estimated cost of $50,000.

“Where do we stop telling kids they can’t do things in Oakville because it ruins our enjoyment of the community?” councilor Marc Grant said before the motion was passed.

“We put in a skate park that has become popular with four year olds, five year olds. It’s a place where ten to 12 year old kids can go, that is close to home and still have fun. Now, we’re going to be moving this across the highway.”

Grant was concerned that council was making a decision without key information from the Halton Regional Police – who did not attend the first, and second meeting.

“It (West Oak Skateboard Park) was built for seven to 12 year olds, and what we learned last week was that 25 year olds thought it was a great little place to skate,” councilor Allan Elgar said. “They were very honest and I think putting it up in Palermo Park will not be bother any residential, and the kids will have a lot of fun.”

The distance between the parks is just over two kilometers. [see map]

Several options considered

Chris Mark, the town of Oakville’s Parks and Open Space Director presented a report to council that outlined the costs and time line of moving the park.

A sound wall which was suggested at last weeks meeting would cost $35,000 – with no guarantee that it will solve the noise problem. To move the park entirely will cost $50,000 – taking up to eight weeks to complete.

“There is no guarantee that if we put it up in Palermo Park we’re not going to have continued inappropriate behavior that we’ve had at West Oak,” Mark said.

“What I can tell you is that if there is inappropriate behavior or nighttime activity, there is no residence nearby that would be impacted by it. That’s what really guided us to recommend that it be relocated, simply because of the impact it’s having on the nearby residence.”

“If we do have continued problems at Palermo, we would look at security,” he said.

Mark noted that if problems occur at Palermo, it is less of a concern there, compared to West Oak Park.

The skateboarding lessons that are currently scheduled for West Oak this summer will be changed to accommodate those wishing to participate.

Debate over skateboard parks in Oakville

Tuesday, June 1st, 2010
Skateboard park in Oakville

Oakville Town Council has been at a crossroads for finding a way to solve the late night noise and disturbances at the Westoaks Trails Skateboard Park. A solution presented by town staff is the removal of the skateboard equipment entirely.

Should it stay or should it go?

Late last week residents that live adjacent to the park appeared before council to express their concerns. One resident described the noise created at the skateboard park as “maddening.”

“It’s always going, it’s not like a soccer game that starts and then ends,” Craig Ferguson said at the meeting – a concerned Oakville resident.

“The soccer field and baseball diamonds are different, the lights go out and the gates are locked. They can’t be used after hours. This place is out of sight and out of mind. It creates a secluded nature where anybody looking for seclusion can go,” he said.

The West Oak Skateboard park is separated from its neighbors to the west by a natural valley, and is surrounded by two soccer fields and one baseball diamond.

NOTE: There is follow-up meeting at the Town of Oakville on June 1, 2010 from 7-10pm to further debate this issue.

The park – installed in July of 2009 cost $110,000 to build – has received complaints by residents surrounding the park, concerning youth that frequent the park after-hours. Graffiti, alcohol consumption, litter and inappropriate language has been reported since its construction.

The skateboarders of Oakville suggest otherwise – and that the people causing trouble are not skateboarders, and are youth visiting the park late at night who do not use the facility as it is intended.

“There are some bad apples that come to the park to drink, but that’s not to say that doesn’t go on anywhere else,” said Wesley Rausch – a 19-year-old Oakville skateboarder.

Rausch spends several hours of his day at the Westoaks skateboard park and mentioned that if the equipment was removed – it wouldn’t stop people from visiting the park late at night.

There are two other skateboard parks in Oakville – one at Shell Park just east of Burloak Drive, and Glenashton Park – which is west of Eighth Line. There have been no complaints regarding the other two skateboard parks.

Several proposed solutions

Town staff proposed several solutions to the problem including the complete removal of the park, it’s relocation, or even temporary storage of the equipment.

The equipment at the Westoaks parks is bolted into a concrete pad – and can be removed and stored. The cost of removing and storing the equipment was estimated between $10,000 – $20,000 – with the concrete pad staying in place at Westoaks Park.

While the complete relocation and construction of another park – will range anywhere from $60,000 – $75,000. Town staff mentioned that these figures are not within the town’s budget.

“If we don’t have skateboard parks to go to, then were going to be skating on the streets,” Josh Ranelles said. “Where are we supposed to go?”

The issue has been motioned to be sent back to council this Tuesday, with town staff gathering information regarding the construction of a sound wall, and that the Halton Regional Police be requested to attend.

Editor’s note: Will the debate over the West Oak skateboard park lead to the removal or relocation of the other skateboard parks in Oakville? Have your say in the comments section below!